chris_gerrib: (Default)
[personal profile] chris_gerrib
Ben Carson, current HUD Secretary, opened his mouth recently and said that poverty is a "state of mind." To be fair to Carson, he was born poor and got himself out of poverty. John Scalzi, another guy born poor who's no longer financially challenged, had thoughts on Carson's comments.

John rather correctly noted that being poor means not having money, which results in a lack of margin of error. To shorter his post, poor people drive old beater cars which, when they break down, they may not have money to get fixed. All the positive mental vibes in the world won't replace a busted timer belt.

I would like to focus on why Carson said what he did. It is a truism that you will find no one more demonstratively against smoking as somebody who quit smoking after developing the habit. I would submit that the act of successfully quitting smoking requires a certain mental attitude.

The same can be said for getting out of poverty, especially in one generation. It's hard work, and requires a certain mental attitude. Unlike quitting smoking, getting out of poverty also requires luck. Good luck in terms of getting opportunities and in avoiding pitfalls.

Unfortunately, recognizing that "there but for the grace of God go I" requires self-reflection and humility. Ben Carson is not noted for possessing either of these traits. It's the very lack of those traits that led him to his current position.

Date: 2017-05-26 11:34 pm (UTC)
nodrog: the Comedian (Comedian)
From: [personal profile] nodrog


        It is a truism that you will find no one more demonstratively against smoking
        as somebody who quit smoking after developing the habit. I would submit that
        the act of successfully quitting smoking requires a certain mental attitude.


I was a libertarian then - still am now.  Do as you please - “It's a free country, ain't it?”

Education, not regulation, is my credo.  “Tobacco is the one legally sold product that, when used as intended, kills its user.”  And what do we learn from this, kids?


Update:  With that said, I agree with Mr Scalzi for the most part.  I'm thinking of a couple I knew who were living on the ragged edge, paycheck to paycheck, and he took classes, got certified in Microsoft Whatever, got a job making three times their former wage…  and they lived high, wide and handsome, buying this that and the other and making monthly payments on same until…  they were again living on the ragged edge, paycheck to paycheck.

There's a lesson there for those of reflective mind.

Edited Date: 2017-05-26 11:42 pm (UTC)

Profile

chris_gerrib: (Default)
chris_gerrib

September 2017

S M T W T F S
     12
3 456789
10 1112 13141516
17 181920212223
24252627282930

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 20th, 2017 09:29 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios