Battlestar Galactica
Feb. 27th, 2007 10:52 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
chris_gerribI don't usually blog about Battlestar Galactica, but I do watch every episode. I didn't get to this week's show until Monday (I Tivo'ed it and watched the Academy Awards on Sunday instead).
All I can say is finally they decided to run a good episode! Two weeks ago, Galactica ran their worse episode ever. Some doctor that we'd never seen before was deliberately killing Sagitarons (sp?) for the not very good reason that they don't believe in modern medicine. Helo, who was in charge of refugees, was the only person who figured this out. It was stupid in so many ways. Specifically:
1) Helo, in any military organization I'm familiar with, would barely be in charge of his underwear by now, let alone politically-sensitive refugees.
2) It's cheap and easy to bring in a one-shot character as a bad guy, shades of Star Trek's red shirts.
3) The plot was an idiot plot - the Sagitarons knew the doc was killing them but they didn't just come out and say it.
Last week's episode, with Tyril and Cassie stuck in the airlock, wasn't as bad, but only by degree. It's another idiot plot - let's all go work in a broken airlock - on the door, no less - but not put on spacesuits! Actually, that bugs me about the entire series, since the first thing I'd do when going to General Quarters would be to put on space suits, at least a basic "20 minutes of emergency air" outfit.
This week's episode was actually good. Tyril, again, had a lead role. The colonists are still trying to adjust to the world being only 40,000 people, and how do we run a technological civilization with so few. The easiest way is everybody teaches their kids to do what they do. Baltar, with the privilege of being out of power, points out that will create an aristocratic caste system.
It's an important point for the colonists to resolve, and highlights the useful function a loyal opposition can serve. Not having the day-to-day responsibilities of running the show, they can point out the problems of the current situation. Granted, Baltar's loyalties end at the tip of his penis, but even a stopped clock is right twice a day. At the end of the show, it appeared like Tyril was stepping up to the loyal "voice of the people" role.
All I can say is finally they decided to run a good episode! Two weeks ago, Galactica ran their worse episode ever. Some doctor that we'd never seen before was deliberately killing Sagitarons (sp?) for the not very good reason that they don't believe in modern medicine. Helo, who was in charge of refugees, was the only person who figured this out. It was stupid in so many ways. Specifically:
1) Helo, in any military organization I'm familiar with, would barely be in charge of his underwear by now, let alone politically-sensitive refugees.
2) It's cheap and easy to bring in a one-shot character as a bad guy, shades of Star Trek's red shirts.
3) The plot was an idiot plot - the Sagitarons knew the doc was killing them but they didn't just come out and say it.
Last week's episode, with Tyril and Cassie stuck in the airlock, wasn't as bad, but only by degree. It's another idiot plot - let's all go work in a broken airlock - on the door, no less - but not put on spacesuits! Actually, that bugs me about the entire series, since the first thing I'd do when going to General Quarters would be to put on space suits, at least a basic "20 minutes of emergency air" outfit.
This week's episode was actually good. Tyril, again, had a lead role. The colonists are still trying to adjust to the world being only 40,000 people, and how do we run a technological civilization with so few. The easiest way is everybody teaches their kids to do what they do. Baltar, with the privilege of being out of power, points out that will create an aristocratic caste system.
It's an important point for the colonists to resolve, and highlights the useful function a loyal opposition can serve. Not having the day-to-day responsibilities of running the show, they can point out the problems of the current situation. Granted, Baltar's loyalties end at the tip of his penis, but even a stopped clock is right twice a day. At the end of the show, it appeared like Tyril was stepping up to the loyal "voice of the people" role.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2007-02-28 03:33 am (UTC)Helo, in any military organization I'm familiar with, would barely be in charge of his underwear by now, let alone politically-sensitive refugees.
He was XO of a major warship for what, just under a year? This might suggest he's suitable for sensitive projects that his time in service would not otherwise indicate.
Or not - they are scraping the bottom of the barrel and they can't exactly send undesirable officers to a shore assignment.
Last week's episode, with Tyril and Cassie stuck in the airlock, wasn't as bad, but only by degree. It's another idiot plot - let's all go work in a broken airlock - on the door, no less - but not put on spacesuits!
Ya that was pretty dumb (I didn't see the episode but I can see it in my mind's eye) but I wonder if the uniforms they wear can't function as emergency pressure suits in some fashion?
no subject
Date: 2007-02-28 02:40 pm (UTC)In the episode, the repair crew were in regular jumpsuits, and a big point was made that they did not have even emergency spacesuits.
no subject
Date: 2007-02-28 03:16 pm (UTC)Because all the major characters would be enlisted. That would be horrible television.
But ya - you're right.